top of page
White Columns
< Back

Toronto Standard Condominium Corporation No. 2376 v. Shouldice - 2023 ONCAT 115 - 2023-08-17


TSCC 2376




In the case of Toronto Standard Condominium Corporation No. 2376 v. Shouldice, a consent order was issued by the Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT) on August 17, 2023, with the neutral citation 2023 ONCAT 115. The case involved an agreement between the applicant, Toronto Standard Condominium Corporation No. 2376, and the respondent to resolve their dispute through mediation.


CAT Decisions - Consent Order


The case of Toronto Standard Condominium Corporation No. 2376 v. Shouldice highlights the effectiveness of resolving condominium disputes through mediation and consent orders. In this case, the parties reached an agreement leading to the termination of a tenancy and outlined specific terms for compliance with the condominium's rules and Declaration. This demonstrates the importance of alternative dispute resolution methods in condominium matters, emphasizing that parties must adhere to the agreed-upon terms, which can be enforced through the Ontario Superior Court of Justice if necessary. The case underscores the significance of cooperation and voluntary settlements to efficiently address condominium-related conflicts.


In the case of Toronto Standard Condominium Corporation No. 2376 v. Shouldice, several key takeaways can be noted:

Settlement through Mediation: The parties involved in this case opted for a resolution in Stage 2 - Mediation, demonstrating the potential for settling condominium disputes through alternative dispute resolution mechanisms.

Consent Order: The CAT has the authority to close a case in Stage 2 - Mediation when the parties reach a consensus, as seen in this case, where a consent order was issued to resolve the dispute.

Terms of Resolution: The consent order outlines the terms of the resolution, including the termination of tenancy, compliance with the condominium's Declaration and Rules, and the responsibility for costs and expenses.

Enforcement Through Court: The order emphasizes that any party failing to comply with its terms can face enforcement through the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, underscoring the legal binding nature of such consent orders.

Efficient Dispute Resolution: This case illustrates the CAT's commitment to efficient dispute resolution within the condominium context by facilitating settlements and issuing consent orders when parties come to an agreement.


Clear Communication and Conflict Resolution: The parties involved, including condominium corporations and unit owners, should prioritize clear communication and conflict resolution mechanisms. In this case, the dispute was resolved through mediation, demonstrating the effectiveness of alternative dispute resolution methods. Encourage open dialogue, mediation, and negotiation to settle conflicts and disputes within the condominium community, which can save time, money, and maintain a more harmonious living environment.

Review and Compliance with Condominium Declarations and Rules: Both condominium corporations and unit owners should ensure they are familiar with and adhere to the condominium's Declarations and Rules. In this case, the Consent Order emphasized the importance of compliance with these governing documents. It is crucial to understand and respect the rules and regulations established by the condominium to maintain a peaceful and orderly living environment.

Legal Assistance and Representation: Seek legal representation when necessary. Legal counsel, as seen in this case, played a significant role in representing the parties' interests and negotiating a consent order. When disputes or conflicts escalate and cannot be resolved through communication alone, legal professionals can provide valuable guidance and assistance in reaching mutually agreeable solutions. Unit owners and condominium corporations should be prepared to involve legal counsel when needed to protect their interests and rights.

bottom of page