top of page
White Columns
< Back

Sidhu v. Peel Condominium Corporation No. 426 - 2022 ONCAT 112 - 2022-10-14

Corporation:

SPCC 426

Date:

2022-10-14

Under:

CAT Decisions - Decision
Access to Records
Adequacy of Records
Entitlement to Records
Fees, Costs, Penalties
Records Retention

Summary:

In this decision, the Tribunal ruled in favor of Norman Sidhu, ordering Peel Condominium Corporation No. 426 to provide the requested records, pay a penalty of $3,000, and reimburse Mr. Sidhu for his Tribunal filing fees of $200, while denying his requests for reimbursement of legal expenses, compensation for "pain and suffering," and "personal expenses." The decision also mandates that the Respondent's board members complete mandatory director training within 30 days to better understand their statutory duties.

Verdict:

Verdict:
In the case of Sidhu v. Peel Condominium Corporation No. 426, the Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT) issued several orders regarding records requests and appropriate actions by the condominium corporation. The Applicant was granted access to various requested records, and the condominium corporation was ordered to create and maintain certain records, including board meeting minutes and notices of leases. The Applicant was also awarded a reimbursement of Tribunal fees and a penalty for the condominium corporation's failure to comply with its statutory obligations.

Lesson:
This case highlights the importance of maintaining proper records and adhering to the legal obligations outlined in the Condominium Act. It demonstrates that condominium corporations are required to fulfill their responsibilities under the law, and that delays or refusals to provide requested records can result in penalties and additional orders from the tribunal. It also emphasizes the need for parties to focus on issues that fall within the tribunal's jurisdiction, ensuring their cases are relevant and concise.

Takeaways:

Background: The case "Sidhu v. Peel Condominium Corporation No. 426" involves a dispute related to access to records in a condominium property. The applicant sought various records from the condominium corporation but claimed that the corporation had not adequately responded to his requests. He also alleged that the corporation had taken retaliatory actions against him. The case was heard by the Condominium Authority Tribunal.

The applicant was entitled to receive certain requested records, subject to appropriate redactions. Some of these records had already been provided during the proceedings.
The tribunal found that the condominium corporation failed to keep proper minutes of its board meetings, which is a significant breach of the Condominium Act. It ordered the corporation to commence keeping minutes of all board meetings.
The tribunal ordered the corporation to create and provide an updated record of notices of leases it receives within 7 days of the decision, as required by the Act.
Current board members of the condominium corporation were ordered to take or retake mandatory director training within 30 days to better understand their statutory duties.
The corporation was ordered to pay Norman Sidhu $200 in Tribunal fees and a penalty of $3,000 for its failure to provide records in a timely manner and its neglect of board meeting minutes.
Additional Information: The tribunal clarified that general complaints about repairs, maintenance, harassment, and misconduct are typically outside the scope of its jurisdiction unless they are directly related to matters within its purview. The case highlights the importance of maintaining records as required by the Condominium Act and responding promptly to records requests. The tribunal's role is to address issues related to records and compliance with statutory standards and obligations within its jurisdiction.

Recommendations: 

Compliance with Legal Obligations: Condominium corporations should ensure they comply with all legal obligations, including the maintenance of required records. Neglecting these duties can lead to penalties and other legal consequences.

Timely Record Access: Condominium owners and stakeholders should assert their right to access records promptly. If they encounter difficulties, they should be aware that pursuing remedies through the tribunal may be necessary.

Focus on Relevant Issues: When bringing a case before the tribunal, parties should focus on issues that clearly fall within the tribunal's jurisdiction. Raising irrelevant matters can complicate the case and detract from addressing core concerns.

bottom of page