top of page
White Columns
< Back

McLellan v. Turner - 2022 ONCAT 29 - 2022-04-07

Corporation:

MT 29

Date:

2022-04-07

Under:

CAT Decisions - Motion Order

Summary:

In the case of McLellan v. Turner, the Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT) denied the Respondent's request to dismiss the Applicant's case, which revolved around a noise dispute related to a neighbor playing the piano. The Respondent had argued that the application was not initiated in good faith and contained false or misleading information. However, the CAT Chair determined that the dispute between the neighbors was significant and within the CAT's jurisdiction. The dispute represented two different perspectives on the issue, making it appropriate for the case to proceed. The CAT also emphasized the importance of informal dispute resolution and the role of condominium corporations in helping neighbors resolve conflicts.

Verdict:

In the case of McLellan v. Turner, the Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT) denied the motion to dismiss the Applicant's case, which revolved around a noise dispute concerning a piano. The CAT determined that the dispute was not frivolous, vexatious, or lacking in good faith, and it fell within the CAT's jurisdiction, emphasizing the importance of addressing such disputes. The decision highlights the need for condominium corporations to assist neighbors in resolving conflicts, the value of informal dispute resolution, and the role of CAT in facilitating resolutions if needed.

Takeaways:

In the case of McLellan v. Turner, the Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT) ruled on a motion to dismiss the Applicant's case, which pertained to a noise dispute arising from a neighbor playing the piano.

The Respondent had requested the CAT to dismiss the case, alleging that it had not been initiated in good faith and contained false or misleading information.

The CAT Chair, Ian Darling, determined that the dispute was significant and fell within the CAT's jurisdiction. It was a matter of two neighbors being unable to resolve the noise issue on their own, making it premature to dismiss the Application at that stage.

The CAT emphasized the importance of condominium corporations in helping neighbors resolve disputes and encouraged informal resolution of issues.

The case highlighted the distinct views of the disputing parties and the need for a formal dispute resolution process through the CAT if informal resolutions fail.

Recommendations: 

Encourage Informal Resolution: Condominium corporations should actively promote and facilitate informal dispute resolution processes between neighbors involved in conflicts, such as noise disputes. Informal resolution can help prevent escalation to formal legal proceedings and maintain a harmonious living environment within the condominium.

Raise Awareness of Condominium Corporation's Role: Condominium corporations should educate residents about their role in helping neighbors resolve disputes. Residents should be aware of the resources and procedures available through the corporation to address issues like noise complaints and understand the value of their involvement in the resolution process.

Emphasize the Importance of Good Faith: Parties involved in disputes should be reminded of the importance of acting in good faith when submitting applications or complaints. Accurate and honest descriptions of the issue are crucial, and any party should be prepared to substantiate their claims during the dispute resolution process.

bottom of page