top of page
White Columns
< Back

Gilmour v. York Condominium Corporation No. 299 - 2020 ONCAT 35 - 2020-09-17

Corporation:

GYCC 299

Date:

2020-09-17

Under:

CAT Decisions - Dismissal Order
Adequacy of Records

Summary:

In the case of Gilmour v. York Condominium Corporation No. 299, the applicant filed an application with the Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT), which reached the mediation stage. However, the applicant ceased to participate in the mediation process from August 5, 2020, despite numerous requests to do so. As a result, a Notice of Intent to Dismiss was issued, providing both parties with an opportunity to explain why the case should or should not be dismissed. The applicant failed to provide any submissions or respond to subsequent messages and directions, indicating a lack of active participation. Consequently, the CAT found that the case had been abandoned and issued a dismissal order.

Verdict:

In Gilmour v. York Condominium Corporation No. 299, the case was dismissed in Stage 2, Mediation, by the Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT) due to the Applicant abandoning her case. This case serves as a reminder that active participation and responsiveness in legal processes are crucial for a case to progress. When parties fail to engage and contribute, the tribunal or court may dismiss the case, emphasizing the importance of fulfilling procedural requirements and responsibilities in a legal dispute.

Takeaways:

Abandonment of Case: In the case of Gilmour v. York Condominium Corporation No. 299, the Applicant initiated an application with the Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT). However, she ceased participating in the mediation process despite multiple requests, which led to the CAT considering her case as abandoned.

Dismissal Authority: The CAT can close a case in the mediation stage under Rule 32.3 if it determines that the Applicant has abandoned the case. This rule provides a mechanism for efficiently handling cases where an applicant does not actively participate.

Lack of Submissions: In this instance, the Applicant failed to provide any submissions or respond to messages and directions, indicating a lack of engagement in the CAT process.

Dismissal Order: Due to the Applicant's inaction, the CAT issued a dismissal order, closing the case in Stage 2, Mediation, under Rule 32.3.

Confidentiality of Documents: Documents and messages shared during the negotiation and mediation stages of the CAT process are considered private and confidential, with restrictions on sharing without the other party's permission, except when required by law, such as for government or court purposes.

Recommendations: 

Active Participation: Parties involved in legal proceedings should actively participate in all stages of the process. Regular communication, cooperation, and responsiveness are essential to avoid having the case dismissed due to abandonment.

Adhere to Timelines: Parties must adhere to timelines and deadlines provided by the tribunal or court. This includes responding to messages, providing submissions, and meeting the requirements for each stage of the legal process promptly.

Seek Legal Advice: If you're representing yourself, it's advisable to seek legal advice or assistance, especially when navigating complex legal procedures. Legal professionals can help ensure you understand your responsibilities and obligations throughout the process, reducing the risk of case dismissal.

bottom of page