top of page
White Columns
< Back

Calderon v. York Condominium Corporation No. 274 - 2021 ONCAT 80 - 2021-08-30

Corporation:

CYCC 274

Date:

2021-08-30

Under:

CAT Decisions - Dismissal Order
Access to Records
Fees, Costs, Penalties

Summary:

In the case of Calderon v. York Condominium Corporation No. 274, a dispute arose when the applicant requested certain records from the condominium corporation. The case proceeded to mediation but was not resolved, prompting the applicant to request the case's advancement to the adjudication stage. However, the case was dismissed under the Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT) Rules of Practice, as it was determined that it had been filed for an improper purpose and involved minor issues. The applicant had received the requested records during a previous CAT case and was seeking a penalty for tribunal fees.

Verdict:

The Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT) dismissed the case filed by the Applicant against York Condominium Corporation No. 274 for improper purposes and because the issues were minor. The CAT found that the Applicant's claim regarding differences in condominium rules was outside its jurisdiction, and the case appeared to be part of a pattern of vexatious filings. The decision emphasizes that the CAT should not be used to replace democratic governance processes outlined in the Condominium Act, and cases must have genuine merit rather than being filed to cause distress to the corporation.

Takeaways:

Improper Purpose: The Condominium Authority Tribunal (CAT) can dismiss a case if it determines that it was filed for an improper purpose. This ensures that the CAT is not misused to pursue trivial or irrelevant matters.

Minor Issues: Cases with minor issues that would be unfair to the respondent to address through the CAT process can also be dismissed. This prevents unnecessary proceedings and costs for minor disputes.

Jurisdiction: The CAT's jurisdiction is limited to specific matters outlined in the Condominium Act. Disputes over the process for amending condominium rules might be outside of its jurisdiction, and this should be considered when filing a case.

Avoiding Vexatious Filings: The CAT may assess whether an applicant's behavior is vexatious and whether multiple applications are used to determine an issue and continue disputes unnecessarily.

Proper Use of CAT: The CAT should be used to resolve genuine disputes and should not replace the democratic governance processes outlined in the Condominium Act or be used to cause distress to the condominium corporation.

Recommendations: 

Exercise Caution in Filing Cases: Before initiating legal proceedings, individuals should carefully consider the significance and legitimacy of their claims. Filing cases without substantive grounds can lead to wasted time and resources, not only for the parties involved but also for the legal system.

Alternative Dispute Resolution: Encourage parties to explore alternative dispute resolution methods, such as negotiation or mediation, before resorting to formal tribunal or court proceedings. Many issues can be resolved more efficiently and amicably through these methods, saving time and costs for all parties.

Educate Applicants on Jurisdiction: Ensure that applicants are well-informed about the jurisdiction of the tribunal or court where they are filing their cases. This can prevent the filing of cases that fall outside the tribunal's scope and jurisdiction, saving time and resources for both parties and the legal system.

bottom of page